Quay cost questioned at meeting

Posted Fri 16th October 2009 at 09:30

The final cost of refurbishing Alderney's commercial quay was questioned at Wednesday's people's meeting.

Renovating the Braye Harbour structure has already exceeded £11m, despite the States originally agreeing a £9.5m budget last year. Numerous unforeseen circumstances, such as the upper berth's weak condition, have pushed the cost of the project skywards.

Former States member Frank Dean said any extra cash spent on the quay would affect other capital projects.

"There seems to be a perception in the community that this project has been both badly managed and considerably overspent. I don't subscribe to these but I would like to know whether we are getting to the point where we know what it will cost.

"We were going to get an all-singing, all-dancing quay for £9.5m but we're now admitting that we have overspent by £1.5m, plus £68,000 on surveys and an extra £275,000 in this Billet. Is £12m going to be the total figure?"

Mr Dean added: "The over spend at the moment almost covers the cost of the New Connaught Care Home. The quay is taking money away from all the other projects. I wouldn't say the quay is stealing money but it indicates that we should be starting to think about pausing for breath."

Chief executive David Jeremiah said a full report on the quay would be presented at next week's States meeting. He went on to say he expected the project to be judged a triumph in future.

"One can always avoid these sorts of things if one doesn't take on projects. At the end of the day we will have a quay which will last for generations.

"Marine projects are particularly difficult and in years to come most people will recognise this as an achievement."

The full States will meet on October 21 at 5.30pm in the Courthouse.

5 comments on this article

Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

gizmo | Tue 1st December 2009
reply to Jusme, when Geomarine first came to the island to carry out works on the new Quay, adverts was placed for the various skilled trades to work on the project, and none of the people that applied for the job wanted to work 7 days a week for 3 weeks solid, Geomarine have employed local labour as much as possible
Giving the circumstances of the project( ie heavy marine construction ) i know for a fact that geomarine advertised for a local rescue boatman which again nobody wanted because it would require 12hrs a day 7 days a week 3 weeks solid thru all weathers.
If you have a look at other supposedly local contractors that bitch about Geomarine employing outsiders and some if not half of their workforce cannot even speak very good english.

regards Gizzy


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

jusme | Sun 15th November 2009
I agree the men here have had to work long long hard hours, and have worked to the highest standards to make sure the quay in its state, has been rebuilt repaired, this quay is alos the lifeline of alderney, although i think more alderney people should have been employed to work on the quay, and less non locals, alderney employment first


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Icey | Thu 29th October 2009
Thanks Blue Jacket. I am no expert in the slightest though the new work on the quay looks of a very high standard indeed & I have been down there myself to see. I am perhaps guilty of not completely understanding the project though do you know if we will still get new showers and toilets even though we are already over budget? I think that I have misunderstood the project from the start though as I thought that the main part of the quay that needed doing was where cargo is loaded & unloaded as that seems to be where the whole is & the only part not to be touched. It just doesn’t look finished to me though as I said, what they have done looks to be an incredibly professional job.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Bluejacket | Tue 27th October 2009
Island Girl is right that the work had to be done, particularly as Geomarine discovered some major voids in the quay which could have resulted in a sudden collapse of the structure. Such a collapse could well have put the quay out of action for months.

It is also worth noting that the final cost of the works will be somewhat less than Geomarine's tender price; the 'overspend' is a result of the reinstatement of work that had earlier been taken out of the contract prior to contract award in order to meet a budget constraint.

The contract has not only been delivered within the tender price but is on programme and the quality is excellent, as all who have seen it will appreciate. The project is a great success and the States members, their consultants and Geomarine should all be congratulated on a job well done.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Island Girl | Sun 18th October 2009
The Commerical Quay project has been expensive BUT.......... it is our lifeline for this island. It is how our food, heating oil, livestock, building supplies, medical equipment, consumer goods etc etc ( I could go on and on the list is endless !) arrive onto Alderney.
Also, on foggy days when the areoplanes are unable to take urgent and sometimes life threatening medical cases to hospital in either Guernsey, Jersey or the UK it is used by the ambulance to the drive to the waiting lifeboat.
It is an expensive necessity and desperately needs to be fully refurbed so we have a safe and stable quay area.
Not quite why the States of Alderney are stalling by putting the work that needs to be done out to tender when the current contractor is doing a good job, has the equipment, concrete batching plant in place and is willing to continue with the work needed and is actually employing LOCALS to work on the quay !!!.


Post a comment on this article

Your email addess is never published or given to third parties.

Name or nickname *

Email address *

Comment

Verification:

Please enter above code in box below

Disclaimer: Please ensure your comment relates to the story it accompanies. If it is not relevant it will not be approved. We will add as many comments as we can but do not guarantee a comment will appear. The Journal reserves the right to edit comments. Comments are not representative of the views of the Alderney Journal


Next story: Quay nightmares for States member

Previous story: C-Permit plans are 'hare brained'

Half price back issues
Back issues up to and including
issue 930 of the Journal are now half price

The Journal's first States Survey

The Journal believes this is an opportune moment to conduct a survey of the States. The aim is to help the States, its members and those who are considering standing for election. Click here to vote!

The Guernsey Bereavement Service has made three visits to Alderney over the past few months and would like to continue to help you. We are visiting the island again on Tuesday 31st August and would invite anyone who feels they would like Bereavement Counselling to telephone the Bereavement Service Office on 257778 to make a time to meet one of our counsellors.

Alderney Journal Ltd, 2A Ollivier Court, Ollivier Street, Alderney

Website designed and hosted by Alderney Web & IT Services