Green light for red Hummer

Posted Fri 30th July 2010 at 12:28

A Hummer has been imported to Alderney.

Builder Mark Maurice took delivery of a red Hummer SUT on Thursday. The vehicle is five metres' long and has a six-litre engine.

The importation appears to mark a major U-turn in States policy after Mr Maurice failed to gain approval for an almost identical vehicle last year.

Mr Maurice's original application, for a white Hummer H2 Lux, was vetoed by former States chief executive David Jeremiah, despite the fact the car's specifications met various guidelines.

Mr Maurice challenged the decision through the courts and spent £130,000 in the process. After his application for a judicial review failed last week, Mr Maurice said he would appeal and seek to import a different Hummer.

The only difference in the second application is that Mr Maurice applied to use the vehicle for commercial, rather than personal, reasons.

Mr Maurice has been advised not to speak to the media until his legal dispute is over. He did, however, pose for pictures at Braye Harbour.

When asked why the second Hummer application had been successful, States chief executive Roy Burke said: "They are different applications - for different vehicle types. The rules governing the importation of varying categories of vehicle are different. Clearly it is not a matter of the colour."

15 comments on this article

Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

AWNAW | Mon 9th August 2010
Do you know what they say about men with big cars........?


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Hello | Sat 7th August 2010
John - maybe you shouldn't. You stay where you are, all nice & safe in your big truck with your guns.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

John | Sat 7th August 2010
I've just heard about Marks hummer application. I remember when Alderney was still a place where freedom of choice and speech were commonplace and accepted. Why can you not have the freedom to choose what type of vehicle you drive and own. He worked hard to own his toys, he didn't bum off the State, he earnt them.
Maybe I should import my pick up truck- ford F350 turbo 7.3 liter, 25' long,7'2" wide and 8 tons, dual rear wheels,
complete with 5th wheel hitch, brake controlers etc. Bet they wouldn't refuse me a permit. Probably have to take my guns out of the truck first tho'.
Oh well, I guess that's why I don't live there anymore, at least here I can do what I want and drive what I choose.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Pinky | Tue 3rd August 2010
Ok, enough negative comments said, I checked out the Hummer yesterday on Butes and have changed my mind. I still think its too big for Alderney's roads but having known Mark since our school days I also respect what he has become and his standing in Alderney as a very good and succesful Builder, let him enjoy the fruits of his hard work.
Just hope that there can be some resolve in the ongoing court case.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Icey | Mon 2nd August 2010
Taffay, do you know Mark? Do you know that he will not be using it for commercial reasons? I don't that he won't so I cannot judge. He has used every other vehicle that I have seen him in for commercial reasons so why not this one? Once again, does anyone read the articles? The vehicle was within boundary’s set by the States so how can he be abusing the law. Try blaming the law itself. It's around a year (I think) that Mark originally put in an application. Are you telling me that they could not pass a law banning Hummers as a whole during that time if they felt so strong about the matter? And Pinky, please….. You re just speaking like a child who has decided to take their ball home because things don’t suit you! Do you know that mark will not win his appeal? Once again, I don’t. I think that he may end up with 2 Hummers and the States a bill for even more than the figures being discussed now. Just out of interest, I think that the Police bike is well over the top for Alderney and the image that we are trying to keep. Do you? Because you are actually paying for that one.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

pinky | Mon 2nd August 2010
Icey, the mockery is the person who has just landed himself with a £130000 legal bill for a £35000 Hummer (white), obviously assuming that he would win the court case and legal fees which would then cover the second £35000 Hummer (red) which he had already purchased and started to import under commercial regulations. So the mockery is obviously the person who thinks its a good idea to pay £165000 and end up with only one £35000 car!


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

TAFFAY | Sun 1st August 2010
The system is being abused because it allows a private vehicle to be brought in under regs for a commercial one. The law is quite obviously poorly worded, because I am sure this was not the intention.

Simple answer - call it commercial although there will be no check on what it is actually used for. Take that to its logical conclusion and we can all have Hummers - and ruin the island.

Which is why Jeremiah stopped the original application. And was right to do so as the Jurats decided.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Icey | Sun 1st August 2010
Once again please tell me how it can be abuse of the system when both applications were within all the limits of the law set by the STATES! To me the States legal system has just made a mockery of itself.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

TAFFAY | Sat 31st July 2010
Who will check that it is used solely for commercial purposes?? Team Alderney? Will they bring back the sergeant?

This abuse of the system sets a dreadful precedent, and makes a mockery of the States legal system.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

TAFFAY | Sat 31st July 2010
Who will check that it is used solely for commercial purposes?? Team Alderney? Will they bring back the sergeant?

This abuse of the system sets a dreadful precedent, and makes a mockery of the States legal system.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

truthseeker | Sat 31st July 2010
Surely a sign on the side saying Maurice Brothers Builders- very competetive rates !!! and a bumper sticker saying my other car is a hummer would be appropriate!!


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

truthseeker | Sat 31st July 2010
Great- i am going to open my hummer dealership on Monday-you have secured the loophole !!

You could not make this up !!


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Icey | Fri 30th July 2010
Pinky, all of your gloating over what you thought was a finished issue and now all you can do is put irellivant comments to the picture. Your funny.


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Hello | Fri 30th July 2010
£130,000+ Expensive for a 56 plate isn't it?


Create a unique icon for your replies at gravatar.com

Pinky | Fri 30th July 2010
Nice to see how Mark makes his mother walk while he drives, testiment to the biggest car on the road having only 4 seats I guess!!!


Post a comment on this article

Your email addess is never published or given to third parties.

Name or nickname *

Email address *

Comment

Verification:

Please enter above code in box below

Disclaimer: Please ensure your comment relates to the story it accompanies. If it is not relevant it will not be approved. We will add as many comments as we can but do not guarantee a comment will appear. The Journal reserves the right to edit comments. Comments are not representative of the views of the Alderney Journal


Next story: Police receive noise complaints

Previous story: Red light for Hummer

Half price back issues
Back issues up to and including
issue 930 of the Journal are now half price

The Journal's first States Survey

The Journal believes this is an opportune moment to conduct a survey of the States. The aim is to help the States, its members and those who are considering standing for election. Click here to vote!

The Guernsey Bereavement Service has made three visits to Alderney over the past few months and would like to continue to help you. We are visiting the island again on Tuesday 31st August and would invite anyone who feels they would like Bereavement Counselling to telephone the Bereavement Service Office on 257778 to make a time to meet one of our counsellors.

Alderney Journal Ltd, 2A Ollivier Court, Ollivier Street, Alderney

Website designed and hosted by Alderney Web & IT Services